Constitution Day: among the best democracies again this year
12/6/2020 |

​​​​​

An overview of the main international indices and studies that demonstrate the maturity and good health of democracy and freedoms in Spain
On this date, 42 years ago, the Spanish people ratified the Spanish Constitution in a referendum. After nearly four decades of dictatorship, Spain culminated its transition to democracy and opened up a period of greater prosperity and economic, social and political stability. 

Four decades later, Spain has taken further giant steps forward within the European Union to establish its position as one of the most outstanding democratic systems in the world, characterised by maturity, diversity and passionate debate that reflect an open, plural and dynamic Spanish society. 

There are many international indicators, studies and rankings demonstrating the good health and vigour of Spanish democracy, its rule of law and the civil and political freedoms enjoyed by its society. Here are some of the main ones. 


One of the top 10 of the best democracies according to V-Dem​


One of the most complete and complex indices that analyse the democratic health of countries is that of the Varieties of Democracy Institute (known as the V-Dem Institute) of the University of Gothenburg, Sweden. In this index, Spain has improved its position significantly to 9th place as a fully liberal democracy out of a total of 180 countries in the latest annual report published in March 2020. Spain enters a top 10 including Denmark, Estonia, Sweden, Switzerland, Norway, Belgium, Portugal, Costa Rica and New Zealand, above countries such as Finland, Ireland, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, France and Germany. 

With respect to other categories analysed in the report, in turn composed of other sub-indices, Spain is in 7th place in the electoral democracy index; 12th place in the liberal component index; 18th place in egalitarian component index; and 26th place in the participatory component and deliberative component indices.     


 

Among the only 20 full democracies according to the Democracy Index 2020 of the The Economist Intelligence Unit


In the 2020 Democracy Index of The Economist Intelligence Unit, one of the most prestigious indices of democratic quality in the world, Spain improved its rating by one position on the previous year to 18th place among the 167 countries analysed by the intelligence unit of the British weekly. This places it among the only 20 full democracies on the planet, in a general context of erosion in democracy, with only 430 million of the 7.3 billion people in the world living in fully democratic states. 

Specifically, Spain was awarded an overall score of 8.18 points out of 10, an improvement of 0.10 points with respect to 2019 and higher than peer countries such as France (8.12) and Portugal (8.03), which are among the 20 full democracies; or Belgium (7.64) and Italy (7.52) which are not. The classification is headed up by Norway, Iceland and Sweden. The area in which Spain obtained the best score is related to the quality of the electoral process and pluralism, with 9.58 points (the same as Sweden, Switzerland, the Netherlands and Germany). In the category of civil liberties it received 8.82 points; in democratic political culture, 8.13 points; in political participation 7.22; and in the functioning of the government, 7.14.





The 13th best democracy according to the Global State of Democracy 2019 of International IDEA


Shortly before the publication of the latest The Economist index, the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA), an intergovernmental organisation based in Stockholm, placed Spain as the 13th democracy with the best classification among the 158 states analysed in its Global State of Democracy report. This represents an improvement of seven positions with respect to the previous year when Spain achieved an overall rating of 0.7705 out of 1, similar to the United Kingdom, Germany and Belgium, and above Canada, France and Austria. 

In the report, which uses data from 2018, Spain is particularly strong in the category of Representative Government, in which it scores 0.81 points and 9th place overall; and Fundamental Rights, with 0.84 points, the same as Canada and slightly better than the Netherlands and France. It has also improved its classification in the attribute of Checks on Government, in which it scored 0.79 and 14th place overall; and Impartial Administration, at 0.84 points and 12th place. 




Among the 20 countries with strongest adherence to the Rule of Law according to the World Justice Project


Spain has also improved its position in the Rule of Law Index 2020, the ranking prepared by the independent organisation World Justice Project, which measures the level  of compliance with the Rule of Law in countries and jurisdictions around the world. In the latest edition, our country has scored an overall 0.73, 0.1 points more than in 2019, which puts it in 19th place out of 128 countries and jurisdictions. Its position is thus very similar to France (20) and the United States (21) and above Portugal (23) and Italy (27).




Among the freest countries in the world, according to Freedom House


In addition to the above indices on democratic quality and the rule of law, there are other internationally prestigious studies such as Freedom in the World, published every year by the Freedom House organisation. In its 2020 edition, using 2019 data, Spain scored 92 points out of 100, higher than countries such as France, Italy and the United States. In addition, it is among the 20 countries with the best position in the sub-categories relating to the electoral process (12th), political pluralism and participation (16th) and functioning of government (10th). 





A benchmark country with respect to gender equality


Spain is also recognised around the world for its progress in gender equality. This is reflected in reports such as the latest Global Gender Gap Report 2020 from the World Economic Forum, in which our country is in 8th place out of 153 countries and territories. Among the areas in which it is positioned best is the political empowerment of women and the percentage of women in ministerial positions, in which it is first in the world. The report indicates that Spain has cut the gender gap by 78.5%, more than countries such as Germany (78.7%), Denmark (78.2%), France (78.1%) and the United Kingdom (76.7%). In fact, although there is still much to improve on, Spain is among the countries with the highest percentage of women in executive positions in companies of between 50 and 500 employees, according to the Grant Thornton Women in Business report published in March. 

Studies at European level have consolidated Spain’s good position on matters of equality. According to the Gender Equality Index published in November by the European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE), Spain scored 72 points out of 100 and is in 7th position in the EU in terms of gender equality, up 1.9 points compared with last year and 5.6 points up on 2010. Our country is 4.1 points higher than the EU average, and is above other Member States such as Belgium, Luxembourg, Germany and Austria. 




Heading diversity and integration


There are also many studies that demonstrate that Spain is one of the countries where homosexuality, bisexuality and transsexuality are best integrated in the world. It was the third country in the world to legalise same-sex marriage (after the Netherlands and Belgium) and the first to establish total equality in adoption by same-sex couples. To this can be added the Eurobarometer on the social acceptance of LGTBI persons in the EU of October 2019. According to European statistics, 89% of Spanish people consider that LGTB people should have the same rights as heterosexuals, making Spain the third highest in the EU (after Sweden and the Netherlands). It is also the 4th ranked country in favour of the legalisation of same-sex marriage in all EU Member States (86%) and the most in favour of all that trans people should be able to modify their civil documents to adapt them to their identity (83%). Spain is also the country in which the political left and right both reflect the greatest acceptance of homosexuality: 98% and 82% respectively, according to the Pew Research Center, in a June 2020 publication.

Integration of diversity is also palpable in the high level of co-existence with people of other ethnic backgrounds, religions, customs and languages. Both comparative international data in Pew Research Center, such as the Eurobarometer, and the Real Instituto Elcano, demonstrate that Spain is one of the least xenophobic countries in Europe and where people are less likely to see immigration as a problem. 




The future in good hands


Judging by the data on our young people in the PISA 2018 Global Competence Report, published in October, there is no doubt the open, tolerant, integrative and empathetic mentality which has made us grow as a society and as a democracy has an assured future. The study analyses for the first time the capacity of students aged 15 to act for the collective well-being and adapt to a world with challenges. In it, Spain achieves a global position above the average for the OECD, the organisation that commissioned the study.

Young Spanish people are in first place among the 65 countries analysed in the category which analyses respect for other cultures, above countries such as Canada, the UK, Australia and Germany. Not only this, but Spanish young people are in 5th place in their attitude to immigrants; and among the ten countries with the best capacity to understand the perspective of others and learn from other cultures. ​






​




ThisIsTheRealSpain
×